11-year-old Montreal girl says she'd switch schools before removing hijab as PQ pushes elementary ban
An 11-year-old says she would change schools rather than remove her hijab, as the Parti Québécois pushes to extend religious-symbol bans to elementary students.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
An 11-year-old in Montreal says she would change schools before she takes off her hijab, and her mother says she stands behind her. The girl has attended her current school since Grade 2.
The Parti Québécois is moving toward an election promise to extend bans on conspicuous religious symbols to elementary students. No legislation has been tabled yet. The PQ is a minority government and would need support from another party to pass the measure. Quebec Solidaire says it would vote against it, and Liberal MNA David Logue has called the extension a PQ move to win Conservative support.
The girl's mother, Mehwaish Raja, says her daughter decided on her own this summer to start wearing the hijab, and that Raja began wearing one herself after that. "She's a strong-willed child," Raja said. "We had this conversation about a week ago, and she told me that, mom, if need be, I'm willing to change schools." The girl's answer to her mother was "No, but I'm not taking it off."
Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon argues the measure promotes social cohesion and lets children develop independently of their parents' religious beliefs. He has compared it to a school uniform. Education Minister Joël Arseneau has called it non-negotiable. The Education Ministry declined to comment.
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association, one of the challengers to Bill 21 before the Supreme Court, argues that restrictions on students would violate freedom of religion and equality rights. Harini Sivalingam, the association's director of equality, said: "I think one of the really sad things about Bill 21 and its expansions and this proposal is that it sends a message to generations of young people that … there is no place for them in Quebec society."
UQAM religious studies professor Stéphanie Tremblay said extending the rules to students departs significantly from the principle of a secular state. "Children are simply attending school," she said, in French. "And now we're telling them we'll protect them from a view of religion that we presume is harmful or dangerous. We could also put them in a conflict of loyalty with their parents."
The Supreme Court of Canada is expected to rule on Bill 21 on Friday, November 27, at 9:45 a.m. ET, and the ruling will address the notwithstanding clause. The Quebec Court of Appeal upheld Bill 21 in February 2024 but struck down the section requiring elected officials to show their faces.