Skip to content
HighOnCity Ottawa
BEYOND

Canada-Ecuador trade deal faces objection from 25 former Ecuadorian officials over investor disputes

The former officials argue the investment chapter rests on contested constitutional grounds, citing two national votes and a 2026 court reversal, while the Canadian government says the rules are balanced and the matter remains unresolved.

· 3 min read · HOC Newsroom
Canada-Ecuador trade deal faces objection from 25 former Ecuadorian officials over investor disputes
File photo: Kampus Production / Pexels

Sources · CCPA Research

★ FREE NEWSLETTER
Get the best of Ottawa–Gatineau in your inbox

The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.

Canada's investor dispute rules are back in question, this time from Ecuador. Twenty-five former Ecuadorian cabinet ministers and former heads of the national assembly have written to Canada's International Trade Minister, Maninder Sidhu, asking Canada to remove the investor–state dispute settlement sections from the Canada–Ecuador Free Trade Agreement before it goes to Parliament.

The agreement was signed in Ottawa on July 24, 2026. It enters into force only after each country completes its domestic ratification, and Global Affairs Canada has not given a timeline for that. Two-way merchandise trade was CAD$2.0 billion in 2025, up 2.9 per cent on 2024. Investor–state dispute settlement, or ISDS, lets foreign investors sue governments through an international tribunal instead of domestic courts.

Canada's stated reason for including it is legal certainty for overseas investors. The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives says the mining industry requested the provisions, and that human rights organizations opposed ISDS during the 2023 public consultations. Its senior researcher, Stuart Trew, said ISDS will not enhance investment in either country.

"It just gives these companies a real sharp tool they can use to basically threaten countries away from policies they don't want to see introduced," he said. The letter's constitutional argument rests on Article 422 of Ecuador's constitution, which prohibits treaties that cede jurisdiction over disputes with private companies to international arbitration.

Ecuador's Constitutional Court used that article to strike down arbitration provisions in its agreement with Costa Rica in 2023. In March 2026 the court reversed itself, seven votes to two. The authors say the reversal came "in the course of a sustained campaign against the Court by the executive," and that the pathway the investment chapter depends on "now rests on a ruling delivered under these conditions."

Voters have twice declined to authorize the change. In an April 2024 referendum, 65 per cent voted no on amending Article 422 to allow treaty-based arbitration. In a November 2025 plebiscite, almost 62 per cent voted no on forming a constituent assembly to rewrite the constitution.

The letter says "a treaty obligation that two national votes have declined to authorize is not a sound foundation." The signatories say they are not opposed to Canadian investment. "We write because we believe this agreement, as currently structured, places that relationship at risk," the letter says.

Mujtaba Hussain, a spokesperson for Sidhu, said by email that Canada considers "clear and balanced rules, supported by an effective dispute settlement mechanism, are key to a stable investment environment." He said ISDS tribunals cannot repeal laws or regulations and can only award monetary damages to investors for a breach by either party.

The Canadian government has not responded publicly to the constitutional and referendum objections. Canada has not set a ratification timeline, and it has not answered the letter's request to drop the provisions.

What we're still asking

Does Ecuador's constitutional position give any legal mechanism that could actually block ratification or entry into force?

Has the Canadian government set a ratification timeline or responded to the letter's request?

We'll update this story as answers emerge.