Alberta landowners urged to stop signing voluntary oil and gas access deals
The Alberta Surface Rights Federation sent a 10-page letter to Premier Danielle Smith on Thursday, saying its members have been left out of talks on abandoned wells and cleanup costs.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Alberta Surface Rights Federation sent a 10-page letter Thursday to Premier Danielle Smith and Alberta MLAs. It says its members have been shut out of the discussions shaping the government's plan for aging wells and cleanup costs, and it is urging landowners to stop voluntarily opening their property to oil and gas development. Under Alberta law, landowners cannot refuse company access outright, so the change would push companies into the legal process rather than end development.
The group's president, Bill Heidecker, put it bluntly. "We've been blocked out of discussions that actually are making the policy. So that's the final straw." He said he cannot prove the September court challenge the federation joined has cost it access to senior officials, but said: "I think our access to top government people has been, to say, impaired since we joined that action." He added: "The premier knows all of these issues. We've met with her multiple times."
The dispute is over what companies pay into the Alberta Orphan Fund. The Alberta Energy Regulator's 2026/27 Orphan Fund Levy is $154.56 million, up from about $144 million the year before. The challengers say that amount is short of what is needed. The regulator says the extra money will help address a growing number of orphaned wells, and declined to discuss the case, citing matters before the courts. The Orphan Well Association reports more than 8,900 wells decommissioned since 2002.
The Energy and Minerals Minister's office acknowledged the frustrations. It pointed to a surface rights advisory panel, chaired by Kris Bower and announced Aug. 6, that includes landowners, municipalities, agriculture and industry, and to Bill 34, introduced in late October to re-establish the Surface Rights Board. That board would handle disputes over land access, compensation and unpaid surface leases. The minister's office said: "The success of Alberta's oil and gas sector depends on a strong relationship between industry and landowners. We recognize there are frustrations that need to be addressed."
Surface-rights applications reached about 9,000 in 2025-26, with more than $44 million paid to landowners, up from $29.8 million the year before. Heidecker estimates landowners are owed tens of millions of dollars in unpaid compensation, though no comprehensive database exists to verify that figure. The province also plans legislation on oil and gas liabilities and orphan wells, along with a framework to test whether companies can meet their obligations.
Heidecker said the federation is not opposed to drilling. "We are not against energy development. We are against any development that impairs other stakeholders or hurts them." The group wants companies to set aside cleanup money, to disclose more about their finances, and for the regulator to be reformed. No public timetable has been given for the advisory panel, and the status of the Surface Rights Board legislation is unclear.