Skip to content
HighOnCity Edmonton
NEWS

Alberta asks court to dismiss Onion Lake sovereignty act challenge

The November 13 Edmonton hearing decides whether the challenge goes to trial, not the treaty questions beneath it.

· 3 min read · HOC Edmonton Desk
Alberta asks court to dismiss Onion Lake sovereignty act challenge
File photo: Carla Tavares / Pexels
★ FREE NEWSLETTER
Get the best of Edmonton Region in your inbox

The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.

Alberta is asking an Edmonton judge to throw out Onion Lake Cree Nation's challenge to the Sovereignty within a United Canada Act. The hearing was held Friday, November 13, in Court of King's Bench before Justice Grant Dunlop, who reserved his decision.

The application asks the court to strike the claim, stop it from going to trial and award legal costs. Alberta filed it in July 2025.

Alberta's lawyer, Heather Campbell, told the court the act is not unconstitutional "on its face." She argued the challenge is abstract speculation, that Onion Lake has provided no facts or evidence of a treaty rights infringement, and that the province had no legal duty to consult First Nations before passing the law.

Onion Lake Chief Pete Chief said the nation's treaty rights existed before Alberta was created and did not disappear when the province came into being. He said the law was passed without meaningful consultation. The nation's lawyer, Robert Hladun, argued that governments must consult when legislation could affect treaty rights, and that Treaty 6 guarantees hunting, trapping and fishing rights, which he said puts many firearms rules in the nation's hands rather than the province's.

The act is the first law of Premier Danielle Smith's government. Smith introduced it as the signature proposal of her 2022 UCP leadership campaign to push back against federal encroachment on provincial jurisdiction. She has conceded she did not need it to act against Ottawa's energy regulations, and that its first use was symbolic. Firearms regulations enforcing federal policy were enacted under the act last year.

Onion Lake filed its statement of claim in December 2022. It seeks injunctions and a declaration that the act unjustifiably infringes treaty rights, citing interference with ceremonies, hunting, fishing and trapping. The nation says Alberta has still not filed a statement of defence, and asked for one in May 2025.

Justice Dunlop's decision on whether the challenge goes forward is pending.