Quebec bar wants 811-style legal hotline and family-fee tax credit
The lawyers' order says Quebec's justice system has become too expensive and too hard to navigate, and recommendations are already with the justice minister.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
The Barreau du Québec released a report this month saying the justice system has become too expensive and too hard to navigate. Its central proposal is a single province-wide phone-and-chat line for legal information, modelled on the 811 health line and called "811 juridique." It also wants a refundable tax credit for legal fees in family matters, psychosocial support in courthouses, and simpler civil and family procedures.
If you've sat in a family court hallway trying to work out what the words on a form mean, the report is about you as much as it is about lawyers. The findings come from a provincewide consultation last spring: about a dozen forums across 11 regions, with 450 members of the legal profession, the judiciary and justice-administration organizations, plus 45 people with firsthand experience of the justice system.
One self-represented man in Court of Québec, in a dispute over a hidden property defect, said the system "does not fix anything," is "very intimidating," and uses language "difficult to understand" that makes people "feel like idiots." He did not want to be publicly associated with the case, and he is not identified.
Another woman, in a custody battle over children and school choice, said her legal-aid lawyer changed three times because the lawyer left for a more lucrative firm, and that her agreed fee "skyrocketed" after the bill had been settled with a private-practice lawyer. A third woman, represented by a lawyer from age five because of her father's violence toward her mother, said lawyers lack training for this kind of case and do not listen to children.
She asked for anonymity. Marcel-Olivier Nadeau, the bar's newly elected leader, said people "feel lost, alone and powerless." He is calling on lawyers to discuss fees "frankly" with clients, to bring more transparency and predictability to legal costs, and to cut unnecessary steps from civil and family procedures.
Of Justice Minister Marie-Claude Sarrazin, he said: "She knows that the justice system needs some love and needs to be more humane." The recommendations went to Sarrazin on Nov. 10. The Barreau says it will help fund several of the measures itself.