Hudson's St. James Church won't rebuild Memorial Hall, the building where the 2024 fire began
The parish is renovating the Large Hall instead and hopes to reopen the church for Christmas.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
The parish has decided not to rebuild Memorial Hall, the attached building where the April 14, 2024 fire started, citing what it called extraordinarily high costs. If you've walked past the corner of Main Road in Hudson since 2024, you've been watching it under tarp, and the church itself is still under restoration more than two and a half years after the fire.
Anyone who has been to a Christmas pageant at the old place knows the Large Hall is the room people actually use. The parish is renovating the Large Hall basement instead, with a new south entrance extension, a kitchen, bathrooms and a reception area. It hopes to be open for Christmas, and the church will use stackable chairs in place of pews. A four-season walkway linking church and hall is planned but not yet built.
Rev. Sophie Rolland has said the rebuild will probably cost more than the church's $5-million insurance coverage, so more fundraising is needed. Volunteer project manager Marcus Owen called the work a "mammoth project" and said the church will serve multi-denominational faiths. "It's an old fieldstone building and there's always surprises when you're recovering an aged building like this," he said.
The fire was not of criminal origin, Fire Department Director Daniel Leblanc said at the time, and an electrical problem was a plausible cause; it started during renovation work in the central building. More than 80 firefighters from nine departments responded. The church walls stayed standing, but the roof and interior were destroyed, and water from firefighting ruined interior furniture and subfloor.
Restoration work now has to meet the current building code. Thirteen stained glass windows were lost; they have been removed for restoration and are due back in the final phases. The new roof is British Columbia fir, built with a more substantial structure than the original.
An earlier roof completion target of December 2024 was missed, and the new roof was finished in May 2025. The parish has not confirmed a final reopening date, but the Christmas target for the Large Hall is the next date to watch.
What will the total rebuild cost, and how much of it is still unfunded?
Will the Large Hall be ready by Christmas, or will the church open without it?
We'll update this story as answers emerge.