Court of Appeal overturns Alberta school board's demand for apology over meme
Alberta Court of Appeal ruled forced apologies are an ineffective disciplinary tool, striking down Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools' sanction against former trustee Monique LaGrange.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
Alberta's highest court ruled Wednesday that forced apologies are an ineffective disciplinary tool, overturning a Catholic school board's requirement that former trustee Monique LaGrange publicly apologize for a social media post.
The Court of Appeal dismissed LaGrange's claims that the Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools board failed to consider Catholic values or acted procedurally unfairly. But the three-judge panel sided with LaGrange on the core issue: the board's demand for a public apology was unenforceable.
LaGrange posted a meme in August 2023 stacking two images—children holding swastika flags above children holding Pride flags—with the caption "Brainwashing is brainwashing." The board removed her from all committees, barred her from public statements about the 2SLGBTQ+ community or Holocaust, and demanded sensitivity training and a public apology. When LaGrange gave two media interviews and posted two more memes afterward, the board disqualified her from her position. She resigned in protest in November 2023.
A lower court upheld the sanctions in November 2024. On appeal, the court quoted another ruling on coerced speech, stating a forced apology is "likely to be regarded primarily as a form of unjust humiliation and not necessarily as a vindication of what is right."
James Kitchen, LaGrange's lawyer, said in an interview Wednesday that judgments about whether an apology is sufficient are too subjective to enforce. "It's a way of setting up people to fail," Kitchen said, adding he was pleased the court reiterated that compelled apologies are a poor disciplinary tool.
Chris Andrew, the board's chair, said in a statement Wednesday that the board remains committed to maintaining a "safe and caring environment that fosters and maintains respectful and responsible behaviours" and that students have the right to a school system "free from bias, prejudice and intolerance." The board said it is pleased the court upheld most of its sanctions.
Does this ruling set precedent for other school boards or workplaces using compelled apologies as discipline?
Will the Red Deer Catholic board appeal to the Supreme Court?
We'll update this story as answers emerge.
By the numbers
When did Monique LaGrange post the meme that prompted the school board's sanctions?
LaGrange posted the meme in August 2023. The image stacked two photos—children holding swastika flags above children holding Pride flags—with the caption 'Brainwashing is brainwashing.'
What sanctions did Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools impose on LaGrange?
The board removed her from all committees, barred her from public statements about the 2SLGBTQ+ community or Holocaust, and demanded sensitivity training and a public apology. When LaGrange gave two media interviews and posted two more memes afterward, the board disqualified her from her position.
What did the Alberta Court of Appeal rule about forced apologies?
The Court of Appeal ruled that forced apologies are an ineffective disciplinary tool and found the school board's demand for a public apology unenforceable. The court quoted another ruling stating a forced apology is 'likely to be regarded primarily as a form of unjust humiliation and not necessarily as a vindication of what is right.'
