Glenn Joyal Nominated to Canada's Supreme Court
Manitoba's Chief Justice will fill the vacancy left by Justice Sheilah Martin's retirement, confirmed by Prime Minister Mark Carney.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
Prime Minister Mark Carney has nominated Glenn Joyal, Chief Justice of the Court of King's Bench of Manitoba since 2011, to fill the vacant seat on the Supreme Court of Canada.
Joyal, in his mid-60s, was widely expected to be named after Justice Sheilah Martin announced her retirement in January. He had previously applied for a Supreme Court seat and was considered the obvious front-runner this time.
"Throughout his career, Chief Justice Joyal has demonstrated the integrity, experience, and sound judgment that service on our highest court demands," Carney said in a statement.
Unlike the U.S. system, Canada's appointment process does not involve Senate rejection. Carney has sole discretion. MPs and senators will have a question-and-answer session with Joyal, though moderators will steer them away from probing questions under federal protocol. A date has not been announced.
Joyal has built expertise in criminal and constitutional law throughout his judicial career. He has overseen major Indigenous cases and worked to integrate Indigenous legal traditions into court operations as part of reconciliation efforts. He is one of the few judges to jump directly from superior court to the Supreme Court; most rise through provincial appellate courts first.
In a February speech at the University of Ottawa law school, Joyal discussed how leading judges must balance traditional judicial reserve with carefully chosen public statements. He noted that excessive restraint is a mistake. "There is now a need for the sometimes bold, albeit thoughtful, action of judges to say and to do things that might, at first blush, seem at odds or inconsistent with that traditional restraining reflex," he said.
He pointed to recent episodes in Alberta and Ontario where provincial premiers—Danielle Smith and Doug Ford—made public comments questioning judicial independence. In response, top judges in each province issued rare public statements defending the courts' independence as fundamental to democracy.
Sheilah Martin retired May 30. Supreme Court hearings resume this fall, likely in October.
