Jury deliberating in high-profile North Okanagan murder trial
Closing arguments wrapped Thursday in the trial of Vitali Stefanski, accused of murdering ex-wife Tatjana outside Lumby two years ago.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
Jurors are now deliberating in a high-profile North Okanagan murder case after closing arguments wrapped Thursday, June 25. Vitali Stefanski is accused of murdering ex-wife Tatjana Stefanski, whose body was found down an embankment off a rural logging road outside Lumby, near where his bloodied Audi had been located by police.
The trial has been ongoing for a month, since Stefanski pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder roughly two years after Tatjana's death on April 13, 2024. Throughout the proceedings, which included contentious cross-examinations and graphic autopsy photos, Stefanski has maintained his innocence, claiming Tatjana stabbed herself while in his car and that he attempted to get her help.
Prosecutor Laura Drake dismissed this account as "incredible," a legal term meaning it cannot and should not be given any credence. The Crown asserted that logic, common sense, and human experience lead jurors to only one conclusion: that Stefanski stabbed his ex-wife to death.
Justice Brad Smith instructed the jury Thursday evening, reminding them that while he is the judge of the law, together they are the judges of the facts. He stressed that Stefanski is innocent until proven guilty and that the Crown bears the burden of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Smith noted that most evidence in the case is circumstantial and carefully reviewed the legal definitions and implications of both direct and circumstantial evidence.
A verdict is expected to come Thursday night.
