Ontario must reconsider about 300 OINP applications after court ruling for workers
Divisional Court sent back applications returned by form letter in late 2025, but the ruling covers only the applicants before the court, not all 2,600 affected files.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
Foreign workers whose Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program applications were returned without a decision have won a court challenge against the province.
About 2,600 applications were returned by form letter on November 14, 2025, with no individual assessment. In Singh v. Minister of Labour, 2026 ONSC 6441, Ontario's Divisional Court sent the files back to the Director to be decided under the regulation as it read before June 30, 2025. Each applicant is entitled to an individual decision, and any intended refusal must come with written notice, reasons, and 30 days to respond. The ruling does not guarantee approval; the Director may still refuse applications that fail criteria or other reasonable grounds.
The ruling covers the files heard together, which involved roughly 300 applicants. Counsel Andres Pelenur of Borders Law Firm said the order applies only to those applicants, although the reasoning speaks to all 2,600 affected persons. The Minister agreed to pay $20,000 in costs, divided among the applicants.
The court split 2-1, with two judges siding with the applicants. Ontario Regulation 149/25, passed June 30, 2025, added a power to return applications without decision for "systemic compliance or enforcement concerns." It did not say the power applied to applications already in process. The province's stated reason was concerns about fraudulent activity and systemic misrepresentation. The government has not responded publicly.
Applicants say some affected individuals have returned to India, and that legal costs for the roughly 300 challengers exceeded $1 million, with each paying between $2,500 and $5,000.