Skip to content
HighOnCity Vancouver
NEWS

B.C. judge rules parole bar for multiple murderers breaches Charter in Abbotsford killings case

Justice Brenda Brown found a 25-year parole bar applied to all offenders regardless of circumstances is grossly disproportionate; Crown will challenge the ruling under section 1 of the Charter.

· 3 min read · HOC Vancouver Desk
B.C. judge rules parole bar for multiple murderers breaches Charter in Abbotsford killings case
File photo: d_odd_y / Pexels
★ FREE NEWSLETTER
Get the best of Metro Vancouver in your inbox

The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Brenda Brown ruled Oct. 19 that the faint-hope bar on parole applications for people convicted of more than one murder breaches the Charter. Her written reasons were posted online Monday, Nov. 16.

The ruling concerns Khushveer Toor, Gurkaran Singh and Abhijeet Singh, all of Surrey, who were each found guilty May 8 of two counts of first-degree murder in the 2022 killings of Arnold and Joanne De Jong of Abbotsford. Their bodies were discovered in the home May 9, 2022.

Justice Brown wrote that a life sentence with no parole eligibility for 25 years, applied to all offenders regardless of the circumstances, is "grossly disproportionate and therefore violates (section) 12 of the Charter." Section 12 protects against cruel and unusual punishment. She said current law allows no consideration of the circumstances of two murders and does not recognize rehabilitation that occurs before 25 years.

The ruling targets the faint-hope provision in the Criminal Code, section 745.6(2), which bars anyone convicted of more than one murder from applying for a reduced parole ineligibility period. A first-degree murder conviction alone allows an application after 15 years.

Toor's lawyer argued the provisions date from 1996, that society and the courts have become more sophisticated about sentencing, and that a 25-year sentence for these men would be grossly disproportionate compared with Alexandre Bissonnette's six murders in the 2017 Great Mosque of Quebec shooting. Bissonnette was originally sentenced to life with no parole for 40 years; the Quebec Court of Appeal reduced that to 25 years in 2020, and the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the decision.

Crown prosecutor Dorothy Tsui called the murders "brutal and callous" and "highly morally blameworthy." She said the murders "showed utter contempt for the lives of their victims" and that the men's youth and lack of criminal records were "largely irrelevant."

The Crown will challenge the decision under section 1 of the Charter, which permits rights to be limited by reasonable limits prescribed by law. The B.C. Prosecution Service said a ruling on those arguments is expected in early 2027. The daughters of the victims, Kimberley Coleman, Sandra Barthel and Heather Hoogland, spoke to media at the Abbotsford Law Courts.

Final sentencing for the three men is now set for Feb. 27, 2027, not Feb. 22 as earlier reported, Tsui said in October. HighOnCity reported the ruling the day after it was issued in October.

What we're still asking

How would the ruling change the sentences the three men receive if the Crown's section 1 challenge fails?

What do the De Jong family members say about the delay to sentencing?

We'll update this story as answers emerge.