Billy Hall was murdered in 1967 and nobody has been charged; a retired Ontario lawyer is trying to find out who did it
A 16-year-old who came to Ontario for tobacco-farm work was found shot in a bush near Pontypool in July 1967. Five decades on, his sister says someone still knows what happened.
The day's top stories, food & events — every morning at 7. Unsubscribe anytime.
If you've driven the 401 past Pontypool or taken the Don Valley Parkway north, this is the country William "Billy" Hall was heading into in the summer of 1967, looking for tobacco-farm work in Bowmanville.
He was 16 when he moved from North Sydney, N.S., to Ontario in late 1966. He had 12 siblings; his youngest sister, Marie McGean, is one of seven still alive. McGean last saw him at the North Sydney train station in November 1966, when she was 12. "There's somebody out there that knows something," she says. "There's always somebody out there that knows somebody that knows something."
Hall had brown hair and freckles and loved bowling. By July 1967 he was living in Port Credit, now part of Mississauga, where he worked odd jobs in the back shop at Hollywood Kitchen. A company employee, Mrs. Robert Cushnaghan, described him as a good worker and said she tried to convince him to stay. He left Port Credit on July 19, four days shy of his 17th birthday, telling family he planned to look for work on a tobacco farm in Bowmanville. He did not name the person he was travelling with.
His body was found July 31, 1967, in dense bush about 15 metres from a roadway near Pontypool, roughly 24 kilometres north of Bowmanville. He had died of a gunshot wound to the back of the head, and one of his hands was missing. Police believed he had been shot somewhere else and his body dumped up to two weeks before it was found, given the state of decomposition. The family did not know he was dead until after the burial; they had not reported him missing. A relative identified the body after spotting a matching description in a newspaper.
His 1956 Chevrolet was later found with a flat tire near Highway 401 and the Don Valley Parkway.
Now a retired Ontario lawyer, Jason Ward, is trying to answer the question the case never did. Ward, who no longer practises law and speaks publicly about mental health and addiction, has built a website, whokilledbillyhall.ca, and a social media campaign asking "Who killed Billy Hall?" He works from newspaper archives, historical photos and freedom-of-information requests. "I am motivated by the fact that someone did a very heinous thing to another human being and got away with it," he says.
His FOI requests for investigative records and coroner's reports were denied, and he has appealed to the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario. McGean says the case has stood still since the Project Millennium detective retired.
The Ontario Provincial Police declined an interview request. In a statement, the force said its historical homicide unit continues to investigate using modern methods and forensic technology, but it would not comment on specific techniques or the details of the review. In 2017, on the 50th anniversary of the killing, the OPP said modern forensic work had turned up new DNA and fingerprint evidence from items at the scene and in Hall's car. The case remains unsolved.
The Ontario government is offering a $50,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible. Anonymous tips to Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477) can earn up to $2,000. Investigators can be reached through the OPP Criminal Investigation Services at 1-888-310-1122 or 705-329-6111, referencing CIB file 955-10-1967-034.
No one has been named or charged.
Who was the person Hall planned to travel with to Bowmanville, and has that person ever been identified?
What did the 2017 DNA and fingerprint findings lead to, if anything?
Why were Ward's FOI requests for investigative records and coroner's reports denied?
We'll update this story as answers emerge.
The facts
When was Billy Hall's body found?
William 'Billy' Hall's body was found on July 31, 1967, in dense bush about 15 metres from a roadway near Pontypool. He had been dead for up to two weeks by then, according to police.
How did Billy Hall die?
Billy Hall died of a gunshot wound to the back of the head. One of his hands was missing when his body was found.